Pushing HP5 to 1600 at the Santa Monica Pier
A night walk on the pier with HP5 rated at 1600, and the development times that worked for me.
The pier at night is mostly neon, sodium lamps and dark water, which makes it a good place to push film. I rated a roll of HP5 at 1600, two stops over box speed, and shot handheld at 1/30 and f/2.
What pushing does
Pushing is underexposing on purpose and then developing longer to compensate. You do not actually gain shadow detail; you gain contrast and usable mid-tones. Highlights get punchy, shadows go black, and grain becomes part of the picture.
For night scenes with bright light sources, that is often exactly the look you want.
Development
I used HC-110 dilution B at 20°C for nine minutes, with the same agitation as normal. That gave dense enough highlights to print, with lamps that still held some shape rather than blowing out completely.
- Box speed (400): around 5 minutes.
- One stop push (800): around 7 minutes.
- Two stop push (1600): around 9 minutes.
Your times will vary with your water, thermometer and agitation, so treat these as a starting point and keep notes.
Shooting tips
- Expose for the brightest areas you want to keep and let the rest fall away.
- Brace against railings. At 1/30 even a small lean helps.
- Look for people lit by signs, not by overhead lamps. Side light from neon is flattering.
At night, the picture is wherever the light happens to fall on someone.
The best frame of the night was a fisherman at the end of the pier, lit only by the glow from a bait shop window. It is grainy and imperfect, and I like it more than anything sharp I took that month.